Craving diverse fall reads as the leaves change?
My Fall 2025 Romance Reading List spans cozy small-town love to supernatural adventures. There may be a chill in the air, but you won't be able to put down these sizzling reads.
There's just something about fall reading—the crisp air, cozy spaces, and stories that completely captivate you. This list celebrates the diverse range of fall reading: atmospheric mysteries, emotional celebrity romances, and supernatural adventures that pair perfectly with longer autumn evenings.
I'm reaching for books that stay with you—stories that make you think, swoon, and keep you turning pages late into the night. Whether it's a pop star finding unexpected love, a witch helping an amnesiac vampire, or getting lost in a town you can't escape, these picks span the full spectrum of romance and beyond.
Note: I aim for a mix of voices, vibes, and tropes. This list is a slice of my fall TBR—drop your favorite seasonal reads in the comments so we can build the ultimate fall romance list together!
*This post contains Amazon and Bookshop.org affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate and Bookshop.org affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.*
Fall Romance & Beyond
From small-town sweethearts to supernatural mysteries—fall reads that range from cozy to thrilling.
A Poem Penned in Poison by Renee Dugan
A relentless “Poet Poisoner,” a heroine with secrets, and stakes that feel deliciously personal. Suspense + romance = perfect autumn tension.
When You Blush by Kristen Proby
Snowed-in sparks, second chances, and all the tender, small-town feels. A perfect "first frost" pick.
Romance Adventures for Fall Days
From spotlights to supernatural road trips—these stories bring the drama, humor, and swoony moments perfect for crisp autumn afternoons.
It Happened on Sunday by Tracy Wolff
Pop star Sloane Walker—dubbed the "Black Widow" by tabloids—meets rising quarterback Mateo Sylvester during her tour. He sees past her armor and stage persona to the wounded artist beneath, but falling in love in the spotlight comes with dangerous consequences. A fierce, emotional romance about surviving fame and choosing love against all odds.
Road Trip with a Vampire by Jenna Levine
Reformed witch Zelda thought she'd left vampires behind in California, but when gorgeous, amnesiac vampire Peter shows up needing help deciphering his past, she can't refuse. Their cross-country journey to unlock his memories becomes a zany romantic comedy filled with supernatural hijinks and unexpected love. Perfect for readers who enjoy paranormal romance with humor and heart.
More Fall Picks
Quick additions to round out your autumn TBR—preorders, new releases, and books I'm excited to dive into.
- Burning Daylight by Emily McIntire (Preorder) — Bookshop · Amazon
- Wild Reverence by Rebecca Ross (Preorder) — Bookshop · Amazon
- Thief of the Night by Holly Black (Preorder) — Bookshop · Amazon
Want More New Releases?
Browse my handpicked Forever Book Lover New Arrivals for the latest titles hitting the shelves—curated for romance readers looking for their next great read.
Explore New ReleasesAs an affiliate, I may earn from qualifying purchases—thank you for supporting the blog!
What's on your fall reading list? Drop your favorites in the comments!
0 comments
Thanks for being here! I love hearing from readers, so please leave a comment below.