Book Blogger Hop: A Book or Series I’d Never Want Adapted for the Screen

It’s time for another Book Blogger Hop hosted by Coffee Addicted Writer! Each week, bloggers answer the same bookish question and hop around to share different perspectives. Here’s this week’s prompt:

This question made me pause — because there is a series that feels a little too close to my heart, one I’m not sure I’d ever want to see adapted for the screen.

This Week’s Prompt:

Is there a book or series so precious to you that you wouldn’t want it adapted for screen, fearing it might be ruined? If it did happen, would you still watch?

My Answer:

Right now, it would be Catherine Bybee's The D’Angelos series.

I’ve even paired the books in this series with comfort recipes here on the blog — Book Club Pairings for the D’Angelos — another way these stories feel lived-in and personal to me.

I just finished Maybe One Day, and it felt like a true ending — not just to a story, but to a family I’d grown attached to. The dynamics were written so vividly that I didn’t just read about the D’Angelos… I felt like I was sitting at the table with them. In the room. In the middle of the conversations. In the quiet moments, too.

As someone with Italian roots, that sense of famiglia matters to me. It’s not just who’s related to whom — it’s the history, the unspoken rules, the way love and conflict exist in the same breath. Books have the space to let those layers breathe. Movies don’t always.

I think that’s what I’d be afraid of losing in an adaptation — the intimacy. The pauses. The expressions between lines of dialogue. On screen, things get rushed. Simplified. Flattened. And some stories need time to unfold quietly.

That said… would I still watch?

Probably. Curiosity would get the best of me. But I’d be watching with one foot still firmly planted in the book — knowing that, for me, the real heart of the D’Angelos lives on the page.

---

For me, some stories belong exactly where they started — in the quiet moments between reader and book.

The D’Angelos feel like family, and that’s not something I want rushed or reshaped in a book-to-screen adaptation.

Now I’m hopping around to read everyone else’s thoughts — and I’m curious to see which books others would protect just as fiercely.

Join the Conversation
Is there a book or series you’d never want to see adapted?

📚 Catch up on all my Book Blogger Hop posts here.