Sometimes the shortest stories pack the biggest emotional punch. When your first love walks back into your life after ten years, do you risk your heart again or protect what you've built? In Wildstone, second chances come with ocean views and the possibility of forever.
The Good Luck Sister by Jill Shalvis is a bite-sized gem in the Wildstone series that proves you don't need 400 pages to create a deeply satisfying romance. Tilly Adams is finally getting her life together - new teaching job, rescue puppy, fresh start - until Dylan Scott walks back into her world and turns everything upside down. This novella delivers all the heart, humor, and heat Jill Shalvis fans expect in a perfectly compact package.
Title: The Good Luck Sister by Jill Shalvis
Publish Date: May 1, 2018
Series: Wildstone #1.5 (Novella)
Genre: Contemporary Romance, Second Chance Romance
Length: ~100 pages
Rating: ★★★★☆ (4/5)
Buy on Amazon | Goodreads
My Review
Y'all, I have such a soft spot for Tilly Adams. From the moment she appeared in Lost and Found Sisters, this snarky, guarded young woman captured my heart, and I've been hoping she'd get her own story ever since. The Good Luck Sister delivers exactly what I wanted - a chance to see Tilly all grown up and finding her way in the world.
What I absolutely loved about this novella is how Jill Shalvis managed to create such emotional depth in such a short space. At just over 100 pages, this story could have felt rushed or underdeveloped, but instead it feels perfectly crafted. Every scene serves a purpose, every conversation moves the relationship forward, and every emotion feels earned.
Tilly at twenty-five is everything I hoped she'd become - still sharp-tongued and protective of her heart, but now with the maturity to recognize when something is worth fighting for. Watching her navigate her feelings for Dylan while trying to maintain the emotional walls she's built was both heartbreaking and hopeful.
Dylan Scott could have easily been a cliché "boy who left and came back" character, but Shalvis gives him real depth and legitimate reasons for his past choices. His helicopter touring business isn't just a random career choice - it represents his need for freedom while still staying connected to the place he loves. The way he approaches Tilly with patience and understanding, acknowledging the hurt he caused, made me believe in their second chance.
The business partnership angle with the logo design was brilliant. It gave them a reason to spend time together while keeping things professional, which created this delicious tension as they tried to ignore their obvious chemistry. Watching them slowly let their guards down through work conversations was beautifully done.
What really sets this apart from other second-chance romances is how honest it feels. These aren't teenagers anymore - they're adults with baggage, responsibilities, and hard-won wisdom about what they want from life. Their conversations feel real, their hesitations make sense, and when they finally give in to their feelings, it's incredibly satisfying.
The pacing never felt rushed despite the shorter length. Shalvis knows exactly how much backstory to include and when to focus on the present. The emotional payoff feels completely earned, and the ending left me with that warm, satisfied feeling that comes from a perfectly executed romance.
Setting & Atmosphere
Wildstone continues to be the perfect backdrop for these emotional love stories. The California coastal setting provides this gorgeous, laid-back atmosphere that makes everything feel possible. There's something about the combination of ocean views, small-town familiarity, and artistic community that creates the ideal environment for second chances.
I loved the community college setting for Tilly's new teaching position. It represents her growth and independence while still keeping her connected to the creative, nurturing side of her personality. The contrast between her stable new life and the chaos Dylan's return brings adds another layer to the story.
Character Spotlight
Tilly Adams has grown into exactly the woman I hoped she'd become. Still fiercely independent and quick with a comeback, but now with enough life experience to know what she wants. Her journey from the wounded teenager we met in previous books to this confident art teacher feels authentic and inspiring.
Dylan Scott walks the perfect line between regretful and determined. He knows he hurt Tilly when he left, but he's not going to let past mistakes keep him from fighting for their future. His helicopter business feels like a natural extension of his personality - someone who needs freedom but also wants to share beautiful experiences with others.
Their chemistry is immediate and electric, but what makes this work is the emotional foundation they're rebuilding. These are two people who know each other's deepest selves, and watching them rediscover that connection is magical.
Series Context
While this absolutely works as a standalone, longtime Wildstone fans will get extra satisfaction from seeing Tilly's character arc come full circle. Having watched her grow up through the previous books makes her happiness here feel even more meaningful.
This novella slots perfectly between the main series books, providing a satisfying bridge while setting up future stories. It's the perfect introduction to the series for new readers while giving established fans exactly what they're looking for.
Themes
Growth and Forgiveness: Both characters have had to learn how to forgive themselves for past choices before they can forgive each other.
Taking Risks: Sometimes the biggest risk is letting someone back into your heart after they've broken it once.
Finding Home: Home isn't just a place - it's being with the person who truly sees and accepts you.
Second Chances: The best love stories aren't always about finding someone new, but about finding your way back to someone who was always meant to be yours.
My Favorite Quote(s)
[Specific quotes from your reading would be added here]
My Final Thoughts
The Good Luck Sister proves that Jill Shalvis is a master at crafting emotionally satisfying romance in any format. This novella packs more heart, character development, and genuine emotion into 100 pages than many full-length novels manage. It's the perfect comfort read that reminds you why second-chance romance hits so hard when it's done right.
Join the Conversation
Who else has a soft spot for Tilly? And can we talk about how satisfying it is when a side character gets their perfect happy ending? What's your favorite Jill Shalvis novella? I need to know I'm not the only one who gets genuinely emotional over 100-page love stories! 💕
More from Wildstone
- The Good Luck Sister (This novella)
- The Summer Deal - Two estranged friends reconnect at a beach house
- Rainy Day Friends - More Wildstone magic
Want to Read It?
Find the book on Goodreads
Read My Goodreads Review
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Love second-chance romance? Check out my other second chance reviews or browse more contemporary romance! 🌊
0 comments
Thanks for being here! I love hearing from readers, so please leave a comment below. Just a heads up - I have comment moderation turned on to keep the spam bots at bay, so your comment might take a little while to appear.