She’s the sheriff’s daughter. He’s the outlaw’s son. Trouble was bound to follow.
Title: Rustler Mountain by Maisey Yates
Series: Rustler Mountain #1
Publish Date: February 25, 2025
Genre: Western Romance
Rating: ★★★★★ (5/5)
If you’re craving a romance packed with emotional depth, rugged charm, and unforgettable second chances, Rustler Mountain belongs on your nightstand. It stands strong on its own while carrying that small-town heartbeat readers love.
My Review
Maisey Yates launches a powerful story that pits history against the heart. In this enemies-to-lovers romance, a small Oregon town—where family names carry both pride and prejudice—forces two people to reckon with legacy and truth.
Millie Talbot, librarian and town historian, carries the torch for her great-great-grandfather, Sheriff Lee Talbot. To revive the Gold Rush Days festival, she needs help from Austin Wilder—the last person she wants to ask. As a descendant of the infamous Wilder outlaw, Austin’s used to judgment. Reluctant cooperation becomes uneasy friendship—and then a tender, electric romance.
The setting isn’t just backdrop; the town’s myths and grudges mirror the characters’ internal stakes. Yates’ strength is emotionally intelligent characters: Millie learns that history can be complicated; Austin reclaims a narrative that was written for him.
Join the Forever Book Lover Community
Get gentle email updates when new reviews go live. No spam.
Favorite Quotes
- “Sometimes the truth isn’t in the history books but in the hearts of those willing to rewrite the narrative.”
- “Love doesn’t erase the past, but it can help you carry it.”
- “In a town divided by legends, two souls found unity in truth.”
Character Spotlight
Austin Wilder — Determined to redeem a tarnished family name; a guarded loner learning to trust.
Millie Talbot — Graceful and determined; a historian brave enough to face complicated truths.
Rustler Mountain — The town itself acts like a character; its myths fuel the conflict and the healing.
Why You Should Read It
- Emotional, character-driven western romance with real stakes
- Enemies-to-lovers done with patience and payoff
- Gorgeous small-town Oregon setting that deepens the story
- Can be read as a standalone
💖 Related: If you love small-town cowboys, you might enjoy this review:
Join the Conversation
Which romance trope captures your heart—enemies-to-lovers, small-town charm, or family legends? Tell me below!
Find the Book on Goodreads
Shop the Book
If you haven’t picked up the book yet, purchasing via the links below helps support this blog.
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Bookshop purchases support indie bookstores and this blog at no extra cost.
2 comments
Thank you so much for this wonderful comment! 😊 I'm absolutely thrilled that Rustler Mountain pulled you in - Maisey Yates really knows how to create that "can't put it down" feeling, doesn't she?
The diary element was such a brilliant storytelling device! I love when authors use creative formats like that to deepen the emotional connection. It sounds like it worked perfectly for you too. Happy Reading. Stay a bit and fall in love with more great books!
Thanks for being here! I love hearing from readers, so please leave a comment below. Just a heads up - I have comment moderation turned on to keep the spam bots at bay, so your comment might take a little while to appear.